Australian Election AI Fakes: From Fake Candidate Videos to Fake Cops

A TV screen showing a fake AI police interview with a ballot box

Fake Videos Start Pouring In

Victoria, in southeastern Australia, holds its state election on November 28. It decides who runs the state government and parliament, which handle hospitals, schools, police and transport.

But right before the vote, everything from a fake video of a candidate to an interview featuring a fake cop started circulating.

Good to Know

How are Australia's parties divided?

Labor
The governing party, center-left
Liberal Party
The major opposition party, conservative to center-right
One Nation
A small right-wing party that leads with immigration and law-and-order issues
Premier
The head of the Victorian state government

Let's start with the fake videos on the Facebook page AussieVoice. In one, a woman in a police uniform is interviewed by a reporter from the Australian TV network 7NEWS outside the Supreme Court of Victoria in Melbourne, and she says this.

“If you come to Australia and commit a serious crime, you should be on the next plane back home.”

Here, “next plane” is a slogan for deporting non-citizens who commit serious crimes to their home countries. The problem is that this police officer was a fake made by AI. And the telltale traces were all over the screen.

The Supreme Court of Victoria is a stone building completed in 1884, but the video showed a modern glass-and-concrete building. The 7NEWS microphone was a different color, and the police uniform didn't match the real one.

But someone who watched it without a second thought could believe a real police officer said that.

✦ 3 Fake Videos From AussieVoice

Police interview
A 7NEWS interview outside the Supreme Court, with the “next plane back home” line
Border Force officer
An officer answering the question “Should illegal arrivals be sent back?”
Woman at a passport office
A sign reading “Do face coverings have to come off?”

AussieVoice posted more fake videos than that.

One is a video of an officer of the federal Australian Border Force answering the question “Should illegal arrivals be sent back?” The other shows a woman in a hijab holding a sign outside an Australian passport office.

The sign reads, “Do face coverings have to come off for all official ID checks?”

These videos are AI fakes too. Signs in the videos showed the nonsense words “SERVICES CORT” and “ENTRALIA,” and a fact check by the Australian wire service AAP ruled all three videos AI-generated.

These videos aren't ads put out by a party in the election. They come from a separate Facebook page, but they look aimed at steering public opinion the wrong way.

〈How politicians are trying to counter deepfakes of themselves〉
* From the official ABC News In-depth channel.

Now Even Official Party Videos Are Made With AI

The parties running in the election made AI videos too. First, on October 31, Victorian Labor put Jess Wilson in a Halloween video. Wilson is the Victorian Liberal leader and Opposition Leader in the state parliament.

Labor went after Wilson's A$1.27 billion health plan, which would let patients on public hospital surgery waiting lists get operations at private hospitals too, to shorten wait times.

Labor tried to build the impression that Wilson would bring in a US-style health system and send medical costs soaring, so the video has Wilson talking about figures like $150,000 for heart attack treatment, $6,000 for an ambulance and $40,000 for childbirth.

But Wilson never actually said any of this.

✦ Reactions to the Ad

Liberal Party
• Jess Wilson — pushed back, calling it a “desperate smear”
• Liberal Party — called the video “rubbish”
Labor
• Ben Carroll — defended it, citing Wilson's past remarks
• Colin Brooks — “Other parties used AI videos too, so Labor can't be the only one criticized”

When Wilson found out the fake video was circulating, she pushed back and called it a “desperate smear.”

But Ben Carroll, Victoria's Premier and Victorian Labor leader, defended the fake video by pointing to what Wilson has said over the years, and the Liberals then slammed the video as “rubbish.”

Colin Brooks, Victoria's Treasurer and a Labor member, fired back that “other parties used AI videos too, so Labor can't be the only one criticized.”

The Liberals couldn't help hitting back either. On November 3, on Melbourne Cup Day, a famous horse-racing event in Australia, they posted a fake video of Labor leader Carroll asleep on a horse. There's also a video of Carroll asleep at a desk.

It's a jab at Carroll's alleged on-the-job nap, which the Herald Sun reported on October 24, citing an anonymous source.

✦ One Nation Launch Video and the Racial Row

On screen
A young man of African background holding a machete, a man of Middle Eastern background in a bomb vest
Criticism
Ties specific races to images of criminals and terrorists
Production
Mark Nicholson, the Chinese AI tool Seedance, under $1,000 to make
Backlash
Richmond Reading Room said on social media it would donate what One Nation supporters spend there to the Greens

On top of that, One Nation's election launch video set off a racial row.

It features a young man of African background with a machete and a man of Middle Eastern background in a bomb vest, and it drew criticism for tying specific races to images of criminals and terrorists.

The video's maker, Mark Nicholson, is a One Nation Upper House candidate in Victoria and co-founder of Stepmates Studios, a political satire production company.

He made the video with the Chinese AI tool Seedance, and told ABC it cost under $1,000 to make.

The video caused a big uproar, and the cafe Richmond Reading Room even showed its disgust on social media, saying “we'll donate what One Nation supporters spend in our shop to the Greens.”

〈Why One Nation's AI ad stirred up so much controversy〉
* From the official TODAY channel.

Is There a Law to Stop Fake Videos?

✦ AI Election Ad Laws Differ by State

Victoria
• Political ad truthfulness law: None. The name and address of the authorizer must appear
• AI disclosure: —
• Max fine for AI ad violations: —
• Withdrawal/correction: —
South Australia
• Political ad truthfulness law: Yes. Covers false or misleading ads and AI deepfakes
• AI disclosure: Audio of 3 seconds or more, plus a label across the full screen
• Max fine for AI ad violations: Individuals A$5,000 / companies A$10,000
• Withdrawal/correction: The electoral commissioner can require it, and the Supreme Court can order it

Even within Australia, the laws differ by state. Victorian Greens leader Ellen Sandell called for a law banning political deepfake ads and governing the truthfulness of political advertising.

The Victorian Electoral Commission says there's no such law in the state right now. Campaign material only has to show the name and address of whoever made and authorized it.

By contrast, some places, like South Australia, regulate fake AI election ads through electoral law.

Either way, plenty of places around the world still don't have a legal framework to stop AI fakes like these. For a while, we'll struggle to identify and punish fake videos.

Political material has long been made by fabricating or exaggerating the other side's claims. But a fake video that makes a rival candidate look like they actually said or did something probably crosses the line of what we can accept.

It's not just Australia. Fake videos made with AI tech like this will run wild all over the world.

Right now we watch videos on YouTube and other video platforms without thinking much about it. But a day may come when, every time we watch a video, we have to first work out whether it's real or not before watching it.

〈How the Greens called out AI deepfake videos in the election〉
* From the official Australian Community Media channel.

That's all for this post. See you next time.

Related posts

No comments:

No comments yet. Want to leave the first one?